A proud Caine Monroy and his cardboard arcade.To let the world of Facebook know it's your birthday, or to not let it know. That is the question.
Crave Senior Editor Leslie Katz and Jim Kerstetter, who runs CNET's enterprise-reporting group, share the same birthday, five years apart. It just so happens that their birthday was yesterday. It also just so happens that they can't stop talking about how amazing it is that their birthdays are on the same day. They've been doing this for six years running now.
But there was a difference yesterday: Katz left her birth date visible as part of the information she makes public on Facebook, and Kerstetter, ever paranoid about privacy, kept silent. Who was right? Let's evaluate their very unscientific points of view -- and get your own thoughts in the comments section at the end of this post.
Katz:
I marked a milestone birthday yesterday -- the first one celebrated as a Facebook member.
Yes, I'm probably unique to be celebrating a first Facebook birthday at my advanced age, but for reasons having to do with privacy concerns and social-networking overload syndrome (SNOS), I came to the site late. To most of you far-earlier adopters, the Facebook birthday message barrage is hardly anything new. To me, it provided a new dimension of birthday awareness.
(Credit: Screenshot by Leslie Katz/CNET) Kerstetter:
I couldn't even say how long I've been on Facebook. I was somewhere between college kids with a coveted .edu address and middle adopters. That said, I've never intentionally shared my birthday in one of those "Hey, look at me, I just got a year older!" apps.
Sure, some folks remember (but not quite as many as you'd think) without that handy calendar prompt, and that's very sweet of them. I can do without the new dimension of celebration. I suppose I've always approached birthdays with a certain melancholia, but I don't see how a few hundred birthday greetings would change that. If close friends forget, sure, that's a bummer. But if someone my wife went to high school with and I met at a wedding a few years back doesn't say "happy birthday," hey, no worries.
Katz:
With e-mail notifications set to alert me to Facebook wall postings, I got regular pings throughout the day reminding me that I'm getting old -- and that people I know and love (and a few I hardly know) were thinking of me, if only for a split second. Yeah, some of the greetings read pretty much the same, but what can I say? They brightened my day and contributed to making it one of the most cheery birthdays in recent memory.
I also got old-fashioned greetings via phone calls, cards, e-mails, flowers, and hugs, but the Facebook notes simply gave the day a "the more the merrier" feel. They also provided a chance to reflect on people I'm not in touch with much but have fond feelings for. Hearing from a former CNET intern I supervised in 2008, for example, reminded me how proud I felt of her progress during and following her summer here (and also reminded me once again how old I am).
For me, birthdays are a day to stop and appreciate life, and some of the people who contacted me on Facebook yesterday reminded me how much I have to be grateful for.
Leslie's Crave cohort Bonnie Cha wished her happy birthday on Facebook but also came over to her desk to deliver greetings the old-fashioned way.(Credit: Screenshot by Leslie Katz/CNET) Kerstetter:
My mom called me. A couple more friends and family sent me e-mails, and two people posted unsolicited birthday greetings on my Timeline. I had a cake at home with a few friends and family, and did post a picture of it. It was nice.
Katz:
It could well be that I'm a fan of the Facebook birthday barrage only because of the novelty factor. When I mentioned my experience to a co-worker, she said she felt similarly on her first few Facebook birthdays, but now sees the Facebook birthday greeting as an easy and generic out for those who don't take the time to call, e-mail, skywrite, or otherwise acknowledge birthdays.
Another co-worker admitted that she likes to talk on the phone and misses getting birthday phone calls from those who now go the Facebook route. A friend of hers, she says, has a policy that if she has someone's phone number, that person will get a birthday call. Plain and simple. Still, I'm not picky. A thoughtful sentiment is a thoughtful sentiment, no matter the medium (though orange tulips are always extra appreciated).
Kerstetter:
I hope we're not having a "Men are from Mars and Women are from Venus" moment here, so I'm trying extra hard to avoid gender stereotypes (though my wife would assure me that I fit many of them).
Really, I see nothing wrong with letting the world know it's your birthday. It's simply not for me, and not just because of modesty. We make it so easy for people to know too much about us. I joked a while back in a commentary that I was going to let everyone know the smallest minutiae of my life on Facebook. I think a few readers didn't get the tongue-in-cheek tone of what I was writing, but the point I was trying to make was: why? Aren't you folks worried about so much unnecessary disclosure?
People see photos of our families, where we grew up, where we've worked and where we work now, what we like, and (hopefully) funny quips about our days on our profile pages. For me, adding the birthday is a step too far. Why not add my Social Security number, my mother's maiden name, my father's middle name, and the name of my childhood dog, while I'm at it? Oh, and a few passwords to sensitive systems at work might be a nice addition.
Katz:
Lord knows (and by lord, I'm of course referring to Facebook here) I'm careful what I post online, and I've certainly experienced my share of social networking-related angst. Therefore, the fact that people have a range of reactions to the value and etiquette of the Facebook birthday shout-out does not surprise me. As April 9 approached, I thought of David Plotz's insightful Slate piece from last year, in which he referred to the Facebook birthday greeting as "a symbol of all that is irritating about the social network."
"Every April 11 or June 7 or September 28, your Facebook account suddenly chatters with exclamation point-polluted birthday wishes," Plotz wrote. "If you are a typical Facebook user, these greetings come mainly from your nonfriend friends--that group of Facebook 'friends' who don't intersect with your actual friends. The wishes have all true sentiment of a Christmas card from your bank.
"The barrage of messages isn't unpleasant, exactly," he continued, "but it's all too obvious that the greetings are programmed, canned, and impersonal, prompted by a Facebook alert. If, as Facebook haters claim, the social network alienates us from genuine friendship, the Facebook birthday greeting is the ultimate example of its fakery."
Kerstetter:
Well, gee whiz, that's even cynical for me. I don't agree. We're talking about personal choice here. I do keep track of the comings and goings of my friends and colleagues on Facebook. It has reconnected me with old friends and allowed friends from various circles of life to meet one another virtually. If Lee, the childhood friend and Yankees fan, and Tom, the college roommate and Red Sox season ticket holder, get to debate under one of my posts, that's good fun for everyone.
That's why I maintain that Facebook is a marvel. In a mobile society like we are today, where else but your wedding and your funeral do people from all the different moments of your life get to interact? Perhaps it's better to ask: Where else do you get to see them interact? I'm endlessly entertained by their discussions and often go out of my way to provoke them.
Maybe I just don't like telling everyone that I'm getting older.
Katz:
OK, Mr. Grumpy. I'll get off your lawn now.
The Nokia Lumia 900: there's a lot of history behind it.(Credit: Josh Miller/CNET) It's been a while since we've been able to say this, but Nokia is wrapping up a very good week.
On Sunday, the company's flagship Windows Phone 7 device, the Lumia 900, finally arrived in stores. Praise from early critics, including CNET's Jessica Dolcourt, is high. So at this early stage, it appears that AT&T and Nokia managed to deliver on the early hype they generated last January at CES.
Of course, we'll have to wait to see how many handsets the company actually sells. It's entering a crowded and fiercely competitive marketplace and it's no secret that Nokia and Microsoft have a lot riding on the Lumia 900's success. For Microsoft, it's a chance to push Windows Phone 7 into the big leagues, whereas for Nokia, it's an opportunity to get its real groove back.
Some younger readers may not remember, but Nokia spent quite a few years essentially dictating which cell phones the planet would buy. It was a time before Android and the iPhone, before the thin phone revolution, and before Samsung set out on world domination. But it was a time when innovation flowed out of Finland as quickly as Paavo Nurmi crossing the finish line. And if that's news to you, here are six things that Nokia did to make the cell phone what it is today.
The 1011
It wasn't one of the company's biggest handset hits -- in fact, I don't blame you if you've never heard of it -- but the Nokia 1011 has earned its place in cell phone history. Its fame, however, isn't because of how it looked or even what it did.
First introduced on November 10, 1992 (hence the "1011" model number), the 1011 could pass for a cheap cordless phone if it were in stores now. It had a monochrome display that showed only two lines of text; it had a nickel cadmium battery that delivered just 90 minutes of talk time; and it did nothing besides make calls and send texts.
"So, what's the big deal?" you're asking. Well, though the 1011 wasn't the first commercially available cell phone (that honor belongs to the Motorola Dynatac 8000x), it was the was the first mass-produced GSM handset. GSM, which now stands for Global System for Mobile communications, remains the most widespread cell phone technology in the world and lives here in the United States with AT&T and T-Mobile. Eventually, 4G will replace GSM, just as GSM replaced AMPS, but the technology made it possible to make a call from and to almost anywhere on the planet. The 1011 went on to live in Europe before Nokia replaced it in 1994 with the 2110. You'll hear more on that phone later.
The Nokia 5110: Resting in a drawer near you.Handsets that everyone had
If you owned a cell phone at any point over the last 15 years, there's a very good chance that you had at least one Nokia. And if you had a Nokia around 2000, I'd wager it was the 5110. Big, sturdy, and available with a rainbow of changeable faceplates, the 5110 didn't offer much by current standards, but it did its job and did it very well. It was the first cell phone I ever owned, and I'm certain it would still function flawlessly today 14 years after its birth.
Other Nokia handsets that reached near ubiquitous status were the 8210, the 3210, and the 3310. Each of these models continued the evolution curve by offering new features while morphing into sleek designs that wouldn't look too out of place today. Yet, it was their cheap price tags, reliable performance, and extreme ease of use that made them huge hits around the world. Other handsets have sold well (hello, iPhone), but it's devices like these that took the cell phone out of Gordon Gecko's hands and put it in the hands of millions. The 1100 from 2003 is another example; it remains the best-selling phone in history.
The infamous 'lipstick phone.'(Credit: CNET) Dare to design
Sure, Nokia's initial designs were pretty dull, but it wasn't long before the company got more creative. Consider, for example, the 8110. Debuting in 1998, it pioneered the slider phone design and starred in the first "Matrix" film (one of many Nokia phones to make it big in Hollywood). More sliders came, including the all-metal 8800 and the camera-equipped 7650. By and large, though, most of the company's phones have been candy bar designs. It dabbled in flip phones like the ultra-affordable 2650 and "fashionable" 7390 and made just two swivel phones that I can remember with the 7370 and 7705 Twist.
On the other hand, Nokia wasn't afraid to break out of the box. Sometimes it was a tittle too quirky for its own good, but even when pushing the envelope, the company was nudging the industry forward. It introduced square phones, models with QWERTY keyboards, handsets with circular and swirled keypads, a twisting phone, transparent models with paper faceplates that you could design, and some of the first rugged phones that existed outside of Nextel's stable. Yet, the strangest designs were the 7280 and 7380 "lipstick" phones that were the showpieces of the company's Fashion line. Though they would drive today's texter insane, they delivered respectable features and great call quality. No doubt, though, that their alternative designs scared most users away; I only saw one 7280 in the wild.
Work and play
Nokia was early with features that we couldn't do without today. The 3310 had voice dialing, the 7110 was the first with a WAP browser, the 5510 introduced music, the 6310 brought Bluetooth, and the 7650 was the first Nokia camera phone. Sure, they still made calls, but phones started to do a whole lot more.
Nokia also was influential in developing the cell phone as a gaming device. Remember the simple, but very addicting game Snake? Though that game had existed in arcades since the 1970s, it won a massive audience when Nokia decided to make it a standard-issue feature. It first appeared in 1999 on the 3210 and continued to evolve into a full-color game with actual graphics. Other gaming endeavors like the N-Gage weren't quite as successful, but Nokia made its gaming mark just the same.
On a similar note (bad pun time!), Nokia's signature ringtone also helped popularize the idea of a polyphonic melody as a call alert. Lifted from a 1902 Spanish guitar composition by Francisco Tarrega, the tune first appeared on the aforementioned 2110 and has been on every Nokia since, including the Lumia 900. If you hear it, odds are that you'll recognize it. This violist did.
The Nokia N95: A real smartphone feat.(Credit: CNET) Smarter smartphones
Basic phones have been Nokia's bread and butter over the past decade, but it didn't shy away from smartphones. With the Symbain partnership, it was one of the first manufacturers to use a third-party operating system, and it introduced some powerful and well-designed smartphones with its E-series and N-series handsets. The crowing achievement no doubt was the Nokia N95. Even today, it's a multimedia machine.
The trouble was that as great as these handsets were, they didn't become global sensations. Though some went on to enjoy success abroad, the lack of carrier support in the United States made them prohibitively expensive at $779 unlocked. Even worse, three months after we reviewed the N95 in April 2007, a certain handset from Apple came along and changed the smartphone game for good. And when Google's Android entered the scene a year later, Nokia and Symbian couldn't keep up, despite their devoted followers and the occasional notable handset. Out of that funk, the partnership with Microsoft was born.
The Nokia 808 PureView: A megapixel monster.(Credit: Kent German/CNET) What's next?
Though the post-iPhone era hasn't been kind to Nokia in developed markets, the company remains a powerful force in the mobile world. Its basic phones lineup still rules emerging markets, and it continues to beat most of its rivals in the number of total handsets shipped worldwide.
The Lumia line could make it a real smartphone player, and at Mobile World Congress in February, Nokia showed that it can get its edgy vibe back. The 41-megapixel 808 PureView won't come to a U.S. carrier (sad trombone), but it has the most powerful shooter ever on a cell phone. Likewise, the N9 is a beauty of a smartphone running on Meego.
As I said, we don't yet know how successful Nokia's latest moves will be. Judging on specs and beauty alone, though, I'd say things are looking up. After all, it has quite the innovative history behind it.
